Turnaround Tuesday Measured at 6x Its Costs. Our EA Lost $40 Trading It.
We tested the Turnaround Tuesday rule on the S&P 500, Dow and Nasdaq 100. With one lot on every trade, it made about six times its costs. With normal position sizing, the same rule lost money.
Does Turnaround Tuesday work?
The bounce is real, but we could not keep it. With one lot per trade on the S&P 500, Dow and Nasdaq 100, 2019 to 2021, it made about six times its costs. With normal position sizing and overnight financing, the same rule lost $40.16 over 121 trades.
Case 024, Turnaround Tuesday, in one PDF: the rules as we coded them, how we tested them and what we found. Free with your email.

What is Turnaround Tuesday?
Turnaround Tuesday is one of the oldest calendar patterns in stock trading. The rule is simple:
- A US stock index closes down on Monday.
- You buy at Monday's close.
- You sell on Tuesday, because the price often bounces back up.
We tested it on the S&P 500, the Dow and the Nasdaq 100. The bounce is really there. When we measured it on its own, it made about six times its trading costs.
Then we let an Expert Advisor (EA, a program that trades for you in MT5) trade the same rule. We set it up the way most retail traders would. And it lost money. The reason for this difference is the interesting part. The problem was not the signal.
Where the pattern comes from
The public version of the rule comes from QuantifiedStrategies. Their rule: if Monday closes at least 1% below Friday, buy at Monday's close and sell at Tuesday's close. On SPY they report:
- 212 trades
- a 56% win rate (56% of trades made money)
- +0.30% per trade
Their free article does not say if trading costs are included.
There is also a good reason why it could work. Investor mood changes during the week. In a 2018 paper in the Journal of Financial Economics, Justin Birru showed that people feel worst on Mondays and best on Fridays. So on a bad Monday, unhappy investors sell. The people who buy from them get paid when prices recover.
People have studied this "weekend effect" for a long time: Frank Cross in 1973 and Kenneth French in 1980. So this is not a pattern someone found on just one chart.
How we tested it
We used S&P 500, Dow and Nasdaq 100 CFDs with one-minute data from 2019 to 2021. This is our in-sample period: the years we are allowed to look at while we build the strategy. The years 2022 to 2026 are our out-of-sample period. We do not touch them until a strategy is good enough to get its one test there.
Some details of the test:
- Every entry and exit happens at the 16:00 New York cash close. We handled US daylight saving time. This way the CFD price matches the index close that the pattern is about.
- The three indices trade as one portfolio with one shared set of rules. We did this because one index only gives about 20 down Mondays a year. That is not enough trades alone.
Costs are what a retail account pays at IC Markets today. Index CFDs have no commission there. But you pay a spread (the gap between the buy and sell price), and a financing charge for every night you hold the trade:
| index | spread per lot | overnight financing per lot, per night |
|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 | $0.75 | $1.73 |
| Dow | $1.05 | $12.01 |
| Nasdaq 100 | $1.50 | $6.81 |
Step one: is the bounce real?
Before we wrote any EA code, we measured the effect directly from the price data. We bought one lot on every Monday that closed down at least 0.25%. We held for one night and subtracted the costs. The results:
- 133 trades across the three indices
- an average move before costs of +0.55% per trade, with 58.6% winners
- after spread and financing, about six times the costs
- a profit in all three years
We also checked the obvious question: was it only one lucky period? March 2020 was by far the best time. The five biggest winners all came from that month. Together they made about a third of all the winning moves. So we removed February to May 2020 completely. The rest still made roughly two and a half to three times its costs.
We also wrote a second script, separately, with its own way of reading the closing prices. It found 5.9 times costs. The first script found 6.4. These are close enough, so we trust the effect.
Step two: trade it with normal position sizing
An EA does not buy one lot every time. Our EA risks 1.5% of the account on each trade. The stop loss (the price where the trade closes to limit the loss) is three times the ATR away. ATR (average true range) is the average size of the daily price move. This is a sensible way to trade, and most retail EAs size their trades like this.
We used the same rule, the same three indices and the same years, with a $10,000 account split three ways:
| trades | net result | profit factor | |
|---|---|---|---|
| measured, 1 lot each time | 133 | about 6x its costs | n/a |
| traded by the EA, 1.5% risk | 121 | -$40.16 | 0.95 |
The profit factor is the money won divided by the money lost. Below 1.0 means the strategy lost money.
So the rule that looked best in the measurement lost money when an EA traded it.
The same rule both ways, 2019 to 2021: Monday down at least 0.25%, hold one night. Left: one lot per index every time, before costs, USD. Right: traded by the EA at 1.5% risk per trade on a $10,000 account split across the three indices, after spread and financing, USD.
Look at 2020. It was by far the best year for the effect. But the EA made only $35 in it.
Why the edge disappeared
Problem 1: position sizing. The biggest bounces come after the most violent Mondays. On those days the daily range is the widest. So a stop based on that range is very far away. With a fixed 1.5% risk, a far stop means a small position. The trades that made the effect, like the March 2020 bounces, got the smallest size.
On some of those days, even the smallest position the broker allows was too big for the risk limit. That is part of the reason the EA took only 121 of the 133 down Mondays.
Problem 2: overnight financing. Holding index CFDs overnight is expensive. On the one-night rule, the EA made $67.48 before costs. Financing alone cost $84.44.
One thing to be fair about: we used today's financing rates for every year. That is about 10% a year of today's index prices. Interest rates were close to zero in 2020 and 2021, so a trader in those years paid less. But someone who starts this strategy now pays today's rates. That is the question we wanted to answer.
The best version we could find
Next we let the optimizer search the in-sample years for the setting that worked most reliably. We only accept a setting if the settings next to it also work. This way one lucky combination cannot win. Exactly one area passed: buy after any down Monday and hold for three nights.
The result on $10,000:
- $150.45 profit over three years
- 162 trades
- profit factor 1.10
Our minimum for an in-sample candidate is 1.30. So it failed.
Where the profit of the best setting went over 162 trades: before costs +$547.47, overnight financing -$364.38, spread -$32.64, net +$150.45.
Holding three nights means you pay financing three times. Financing took two-thirds of the profit before costs.
The indices also did not agree with each other:
- The Nasdaq 100 made money on its own.
- The Dow lost money.
- The S&P 500 roughly broke even.
A portfolio rule that only works on one of its three markets is not the pattern we wanted to test.
It failed in-sample, so we never ran it on 2022 to 2026. Those years stay untouched for this idea.
What this means if you want to trade it
The bounce after a down Monday is in the price data. It shows up across three years and three indices. But we could not keep that profit in a retail CFD account with sensible risk management.
If you want to try it yourself, change the two things that broke it here:
- Use the same amount of money on every trade. Do not make the position smaller when the market moves a lot. Then the big bounce days get full size. But be honest with yourself: this also means more risk on those days.
- Hold it somewhere without a nightly financing charge. For example, an ETF in a cash account, or futures.
We have not tested either version. So please treat them as ideas, not results.
Most backtests of this pattern that you will find use a fixed size and leave out financing. Add those two things back in and, with our numbers, the edge is gone.
Case 024 in one PDF: the exact rules, how we tested them, and what we found. Your email unlocks it and the other 26 case files, plus every new one as it lands.
Send us your rules or your MT5 EA. We run them through the same tests as this post, with real broker costs and data the strategy has never seen, and give you a plain verdict.
Run the numbers yourself
The free calculators behind the sizing and robustness checks in this test. No signup.