Skip to content
← Blog · 2026-10-01 · forward-test · monte carlo · statistics · MetaTrader 5 · risk-management

Edge or Luck? We Ran Our Own Forward Test Through a Free MT5 Check

Is your average trade really good, or was it luck? A simple test with your closed trades can tell you. We used our free YuRaLytics panel on our three demo forward-test accounts.

Short answer

How can I tell if my EA's profit is an edge or just luck?

Take your closed trades and pick them at random, 10,000 times. A trade can be picked more than once. Then look at the middle 95% of the averages. If that whole range is above zero, the edge looks real for those trades. If the range includes zero, it could still be luck. With fewer than about 30 trades, the test cannot tell.

THE BACKTEST FILES
Get the rules behind every verdict

The Backtest Files: the exact rules of each strategy we've put on trial, how we tested it and what the data showed. Free with your email.

We use your email to send the link to the files, and nothing else unless you tick the box. Privacy

Edge or Luck? We Ran Our Own Forward Test Through a Free MT5 Check

Good results can still be luck

Our range breakout forward test has made 44 trades so far. A forward test means we run the strategy on a live market, here on a demo account, after the backtest is done. The account started with 11,000 GBP and is now up 2,282.90 GBP. The profit factor (gross profit divided by gross loss) is 2.47, and the win rate is 50%.

We trust numbers like these the least. Two good months can happen for almost any reason.

Every EA owner asks the same question: is this a real edge, or a lucky run? Net profit cannot answer it. Profit factor cannot answer it either. These numbers show what happened. They do not show how easily it could have happened by chance.

So we built a free MetaTrader 5 panel to answer that question. It is called YuRaLytics Trade Analyzer. The most honest way to show it is to use it on our own forward test, including the parts that do not look good for us.

How the test works

Here are the steps:

  • Take your closed trades. In our case there are 44.
  • Pick 44 trades at random from that list. After each pick, put the trade back. So some trades are picked twice, and some are not picked at all.
  • Work out the average trade.
  • Do this 10,000 times.

Now you have 10,000 versions of your trade history. Each one could just as easily have happened. Look at the middle 95% of their averages. Your true average trade is most likely inside this range. Statisticians call this method a bootstrap.

How to read it:

  • If the whole range is above zero, the edge looks real for these trades.
  • If the range includes zero, you cannot say it is not luck yet.

The bootstrap does not assume anything about the shape of your results. This is important in trading. Often a few big winners make the whole result, so a normal bell curve is the wrong model.

Our three forward-test accounts

Each strategy runs on its own IC Markets demo account. You can see every trade on the forward test page. This is what the panel showed when we checked it on 1 October 2026:

accountclosed tradesaverage trade95% range of the averagechance the true average is below zero
Range breakout, USD/JPY44+51.88 GBP+6.70 to +101.05 GBP1.2%
Gotobi, EUR/JPY12+23.58 GBP+2.42 to +43.63 GBP1.6%
Gotobi Tokyo fix, USD/JPY12+13.60 GBP-4.11 to +30.66 GBP6.6%

Each account gives a different answer. Those differences are the useful part.

Range breakout: above zero, but the range is very wide

The Edge or luck tab on the range breakout demo account: 44 trades, average +51.88 GBP, 95% range +6.70 to +101.05 GBP, 1.2% chance the true average is below zero.The Edge or luck tab on the range breakout demo account: 44 trades, average +51.88 GBP, 95% range +6.70 to +101.05 GBP, 1.2% chance the true average is below zero.

The whole range is above zero. So for these 44 trades, the panel says the edge looks real.

But look at the size of the range: +6.70 to +101.05 per trade. The low end is about one eighth of the average we have seen so far. The data fits an edge that small just as well.

This matters because the forward test is doing much better than the backtest. We tested the same rules on 1,012 out-of-sample trades from 2022 to 2025. Out-of-sample means data the strategy was not built on. That test had a profit factor of 1.16. In the forward test, it is 2.47.

The bootstrap says the average is probably above zero. It cannot know if two months of trading look like the next two years. We expect the profit factor to move back toward the backtest number. When it does, we will publish it.

Gotobi EUR/JPY: above zero, but no answer yet

This account has 12 trades. The whole range is above zero, and there is only a 1.6% chance of a negative average. From the numbers alone, you might say it works.

The panel does not say that. With fewer than 30 trades, it says the sample is too small to judge. (30 is the default setting, and you can change it.)

Why? With only 12 trades, the bootstrap can only mix those 12 trades. It never sees the losses that have not happened yet. Ten of the twelve trades were winners. That win rate will not last. Until the losing trades come, the range is too narrow and too confident.

30 trades is the minimum we would accept. Many strategies need far more before the range means much.

Gotobi Tokyo fix: could still be luck

The range goes from -4.11 to +30.66, so zero is inside it. There is a 6.6% chance that the true average is below zero.

With 12 trades it is under the minimum anyway. But even without that rule, the answer would be "we cannot tell yet". This strategy trades about six times a month and has run for two months. So "we cannot tell yet" is the right answer.

Is the drawdown normal?

A drawdown is how far the account falls from its highest point. When an EA is losing money, traders ask: is it broken, or is this normal for it?

The panel answers this with a different shuffle. It puts the same 44 trades in 10,000 random orders. For each order, it records the worst drawdown.

For the range breakout:

  • Our worst drawdown so far is 414.54 GBP.
  • In the shuffles, the typical worst drawdown is 411.56 GBP.
  • 1 order in 20 has a drawdown worse than 673.99 GBP.

So our drawdown is ordinary. Right now the account is 287.54 GBP below its highest point. That is also well inside the normal range.

If an account falls past that 1-in-20 line, there are two possible reasons. The trades came in an unusually bad order, or the strategy has changed. The panel can warn you when this happens, with a pop-up or a push notification to the MetaTrader app. This alert is off by default.

One warning about the alert. The shuffle only uses trades you already have. A strategy that is breaking down often makes new kinds of losses. So when the alert fires, go and check what the EA has been doing. The alert alone does not prove that anything is broken.

Losing streaks

The Behaviour tab: buys against sells, average time in winning and losing trades, and the longest losing run of 6 trades, which 23.5% of reshuffles match or beat.The Behaviour tab: buys against sells, average time in winning and losing trades, and the longest losing run of 6 trades, which 23.5% of reshuffles match or beat.

The longest losing streak on this account is six trades. We shuffled the same trades many times. In 23.5% of the shuffles, a streak this long or longer appears.

Six losses in a row feels bad while you watch it. But for these trades, it is normal.

There is a second optional alert for this. It fires when the current losing streak gets so long that fewer than 1 in 20 shuffles have a streak that long.

Trading costs

The Summary tab: 44 trades, net +2,282.90 GBP, gross +2,432.96 GBP, commission -150.06 GBP, swap zero, maximum drawdown -414.54 GBP.The Summary tab: 44 trades, net +2,282.90 GBP, gross +2,432.96 GBP, commission -150.06 GBP, swap zero, maximum drawdown -414.54 GBP.

On this account, the gross profit (before costs) was 2,432.96 GBP. Commission took 150.06 GBP of that, or 6.2%. Swap (the fee for holding a trade overnight) was zero, because the strategy closes its trades on the same day. The panel reads these costs directly from the broker's records. So they match what you really paid.

6.2% is low because the average trade is large right now. In the backtest of the same strategy, the average trade was smaller. There, commission took about a quarter of the gross profit. Check this share on every EA you run.

What the panel cannot tell you

Every number above is about trades that already happened. The panel cannot tell you if the future will look like the past. It cannot tell you if two months of one market is a fair sample of the next year.

It also counts a trade only after the position is closed. Open positions are not in any of these numbers.

Try it on your own account

YuRaLytics Trade Analyzer is free on the MQL5 Market. Attach it to any chart. It only reads your history. It never opens, changes or closes a trade, so you can run it next to live EAs.

It splits all results by magic number (the ID an EA puts on its trades) and by symbol. So if your account runs several EAs, you get one answer for each EA, not one mixed answer.

Maybe you only want the edge-or-luck test, or you want to see exactly how it works. The same calculation is also a single free script with full source code: Edge or Luck on the MQL5 Code Base. Run it on any chart. It prints the 95% range of your average trade and the chance that the true average is below zero. You can run it on one magic number, one symbol or the last N days.

We will keep checking our own forward test with it and publishing the results, also when the answer gets worse.

THE BACKTEST FILES
Get every rulebook, free

The exact rules of every strategy we've put on trial, how we tested each one, and what the data showed. 27 case files so far, free with your email.

We use your email to send the link to the files, and nothing else unless you tick the box. Privacy

STRATEGY AUDIT
Have a strategy of your own? Get it tested the same way.

Send us your rules or your MT5 EA. We run them through the same tests as this post, with real broker costs and data the strategy has never seen, and give you a plain verdict.